The DC Universe is ending!!!!!
….again.
And because I am behind on the current events of dead fictional universes, I’m writing a list of fifteen fantastic titles from DC Comics’ The New 52 universe. But first, in case you’re new to comics, I’m gonna provide you a quick explanation for WHY the DC Universe is rebooting. So, if you want to skip the details and just enjoy the stories, then fine, be that way. You can skip ahead, see the good stuff at the end, but then you won’t get to read all the juicy details. Your loss.
For those of you who didn’t know, DC Comics rebooted their universe back in 2011 and started anew. After 25 years of uninterrupted stories, it was just getting hard to follow everything. This was a chance to give new readers a chance to get to know the characters, and it turned out pretty well. But there were some notable problems.
Some titles like Justice League and The Flash restarted from scratch, while other titles like Green Lantern and Batman seemed to carry over from the old universe, making there a lot of inconsistencies. A few titles, such as Batgirl and Batwoman, simultaneously had original elements and references to stories from the previous universe. So there were continuity issues, to say the least.
Also, there were some issues where women were sometimes drawn or written more like big-boobed sex objects and where several characters of color mysteriously disappeared from existence. Naturally, the internet responded with rage, criticism, and emojis of moral indignation.
This new universe, called The New 52, got better over the past four years, and DC addressed a lot of these issues. However, it seems the problems with continuity could not be salvaged, so now DC is writing a big crossover event in which they are combining every alternate reality, alternate timeline, and previous reality-altering crossover event into one colossal story. The story is called Convergence.
With the ending of The New 52 in Convergence, I thought people deserved to know some of the best DC comics written in the past four years. Sadly, because I don’t have millions of dollars to spend on comics, I haven’t read everything, so there are some really good Superman and Green Lantern stories I’ve heard about, but I never got to reading all of those so they’re not on the list (because I won’t recommend to you what I can’t personally vouch for). Also, there is a disproportionate number of white straight characters in comics, and that is reflected in this list. (I could have included the Static Shock book, as I love the character immensely, but the story just felt too convoluted to make my list).
But here it is at last….[DRUM ROLL] The top fifteen trade paperbacks from The New 52!
15. Justice League vol 1: Origin
If the title didn’t give it away, this is [gasp!] the Justice League’s origin story, and believe me, it’s as funny as it is epic. The basic premise involves Batman and Green Lantern meeting as they both try to identify an otherworldly attacker, only to bump heads with Superman, then the Flash, and eventually drag in several other heroes as a few robo-aliens turn out to be the prelude to a full on invasion from Apokolips! The story is straightforward and much of the dialogue is clunky. But it’s hilarious. Writer Geoff Johns understands comedy, and more importantly, he knows the characters better than they know themselves. Also, Jim Lee’s artwork is absolutely breath-taking.
14. Wonder Woman vol 1: Blood
Confession: I didn’t like this. Wonder Woman was one of the best titles of The New 52, and people loved it! But this isn’t MY Wonder Woman, so I’m biased here. The story is compelling, and Brian Azzarello is a magnificent writer with a brilliant grasp of language. The art is also gorgeous, with Cliff Chiang giving us dynamic scenes of conflict that leap off the page. But this is not the Wonder Woman of the previous universe and the portrayal of mythological elements was jarring and felt out of place both in the context of superheroics and the original myths. Still, it’s worthy of checking out, and it spawned five sequel volumes that kept fans raving so don’t let my biases keep you from the series. If it wasn’t great, it wouldn’t be on the list.
13. Superman Action Comics vol 1: Superman and the Men of Steel
This is the origin of a young arrogant Superman making himself known in Metropolis. He’s a young idealistic guy standing up against economic injustices. And in his secret identity as broke blogger Clark Kent, he writes about these issues. Then things get real. Not only does “the man” (aka., the military industrial complex) put him in his place, but suddenly aliens invade and there are robotic armies attacking Metropolis. While this sounds like a mere action hero story, it’s so much more, and a great example of Grant Morrison exploring the nature of the modern myth of one man fighting cosmic forces and social injustices in the pursuit of doing the right thing.
12. Aquaman vol 1: The Trench
Aquaman is the biggest joke in modern comics. I mean, his power is TALKING TO FISH! Except, if you actually READ the comics, you know this isn’t true! Writer Geoff Johns knows people take Aquaman for granted, but he also knows just how badass the hero really is! We get great scenes here of Aquaman showing up to stop a crime, and the cops shaking their heads as they wonder why they couldn’t have gotten any other hero. Or the scene where Aquaman eats in his favorite seafood restaurant. But beyond these moments, we also see him face a threat coming out of the sea—a race of subaquatic predatory menfolk whose lack of a food source has driven them to attack the shore. It’s a story with real feelings, real consequences, and a villain whose motive is fighting against impending extinction. This is a must read!
11. The Flash vol 1: Move Forward
Do you like the Flash TV show? It doesn’t matter! Because this comic is so much better than the show that you’ll be racing to your nearest comic shop to get its sequel! This story focuses on two villains. The first is Barry Allen (AKA, The Flash)’s old friend, Manuel Lago, who has been turned into Mob Rule, a villain with the power to replicate copies of himself. The second is Captain Cold, who has broken out of prison to wreak havoc on the city as he has internalized the cold powers of his freeze gun. What makes this piece so great is its exploration of characters and its handling of advanced physics. Also, Francis Manapul and Brian Buccellato provide us with dynamic art full of flashy colors that really capture the element of movement in the story.
10. Green Lantern Corps vol 1: Fearsome
It’s easy to forget Earth isn’t the center of the universe, especially in comics where half of the cosmic heroes seem to come from earth (and all the aliens seem interested in invading our prime real estate). Green Lantern Corps is a comic focusing on, well, the eponymous Green Lantern Corps, the interstellar police force tasked with using their power rings to keep the galaxy safe. In particular, the series focuses on two Green Lanterns of Earth, John Stewart and Guy Gardner. One of the things about the Green Lanterns is they’ve realized that Earthlings are unreasonably stubborn—something incredibly useful since their Green Lantern rings are powered by willpower. But another aspect about the Green Lanterns is that their leaders, the tiny blue men known as the Guardians, are essentially space fascists who commonly are willing to inflict unmeasurable suffering to meet their goals. In this story, some of the horrors of the Guardians’ past are brought to light, while Guy and John battle foes who are immune to their power rings. This is a story of moral ambiguities and complex emotional developments that explores many of the technicalities of what being a Green Lantern means. I can’t recommend this enough.
9. Forever Evil
Good guys are boring. And it’s not their fault, but those law-and-order types just don’t have the same appeal as the bad boys, bad girls, and bad evil pirate ninja robot aliens. Think about it. Batman is the coolest superhero ever. Batman is just one kill away from crossing the line into villainy. So, here we have a story of all villains. The Justice League is dead. They have been replaced by their evil counterparts from another dimension—the Crime Syndicate. As the Crime Syndicate takes over the earth and quashes any remaining heroes (like Nightwing and the Teen Titans), they rally other villains to their cause. But some villains won’t go down so easily. Lex Luthor won’t let ANYONE else rule his planet. The Rogues from Central City are happy to blow up a hospital, but they want to evacuate it first since they have their code against killing. And Black Manta? Black Manta’s sole purpose in life is to kill Aquaman, and the Crime Syndicate stole that from him. He will make them suffer!
This is an amazing crossover where we get to see the villains exposed for the people they are—rather than just plot devices for our heroes to stop. And among the characters we get to meet is the Crime Syndicate’s evil version of Batman, called Owlman, who is even darker than Gotham’s familiar Dark Knight.
8. Batman and Robin vol 1: Born to Kill
Don’t think of this as a superhero story. Think of this as a story of an estranged father and his homicidal son who was raised by ninjas. A true heartfelt father-son epic with lots of feely emotions. Like so many of the stories on this list, it features a new villain [DUN DUN DUNNNN!]. Unlike the other stories, I really don’t care about the villain, because the greater conflict is whether the father (Batman) can impart the lessons he’s trying to on his son (Damian Wayne, AKA Robin). The art is beautiful, and this is the story that got me paying attention to writer Peter Tomasi (who has yet to write a story I didn’t like).
7. Batwing vol 1: The Lost Kingdom
If you’re new to comics, you need to know there are two Batwings. Okay, technically, there are three—the third (or really, the original) being Batman’s private stealth jet. However, this story focuses on David Zavimbe, the first of the two characters to don the mantle of Batwing as his superhero nom de gare. A Congolese policeman, David was hired by Batman to fight crime as an African superhero, and provided with the equipment and training necessary for such a task. Most of Africa’s former superhero team, the Kingdom, have been missing for years. But suddenly the heroes from the Kingdom are being killed by a villain named Massacre. The story describes child soldiers, local warlords and police corruption with a frank honesty that makes it one of the boldest stories DC has produced in recent years, and writer Judd Winick did amazing work with this title. This comic offers a perspective sorely lacking in modern comics.
6. Demon Knights vol 1: Seven Against the Dark
One problem with comics is they all seem to feature people in spandex punching their problems away in haphazard free-for-alls of collateral damage. Thankfully, Demon Knights breaks that trend by offering us a story of Camelot, drunken Vandal warlords, invading armies, velociraptor dragons, bawdy jokes, and tavern brawls! This story was part of DC’s horror run–the Dark. Except it’s far too funny and clever to be labeled mere horror. It is actually my favorite team book produced by The New 52. This is a medieval tale worthy of the troubadours of old, and just as ribald, rude, and over-the-top. It features old and new DC heroes, and actually has some fun archaic references for anyone who enjoys medieval history. So sit down at a trencher table, swig a horn of mead, and enjoy this illuminated grimoire of comic madness.
5. Batgirl vol 3: Death of the Family
Gail Simone’s run of Batgirl is one of the best things to happen to comics. Being a woman, Gail Simone took objection to how often women in comics were brutalized. So she used the opportunity of The New 52 to reboot the character of Barbara Gordon as Batgirl—a character whose superhero career came to an end in the last universe after the Joker shot her through the spine, stripped her naked, and tortured her. While everything Gail Simone wrote for Batgirl is fantastic, the third volume is particularly poignant. Part of the “Death of the Family” story arc, this shows the Joker hunting down each of Batman’s allies, forcing Barbara to confront the man who still haunts her nightmares. On top of all that, she also has to deal with her sociopathic serial killer of a brother, juggle her love life, and have a heartfelt moment with her roommate that I won’t spoil for you. This series (and particularly this book) is smart, bold, and honest. More importantly, it sees crime not as bad guys opposing good guys, but as a phenomena of violence driven by economics and human psychology.
4. Animal Man vol 1: The Hunt
While Animal Man was once a costumed hero, this is actually a horror story. Buddy Baker is a father, husband, activist, actor, and still recognized by the public as the (former) superhero Animal Man who can mimic the powers of animals. But when the personification of rot rises up to attack his family, there’s only so much he can do. He’s not the savior, after all. His six-year-old daughter is, and he doesn’t know if he’s strong enough to keep her safe from the things coming to kill her. This story is one filled with grim body horror, nightmares, and zombies, but the real drive comes from how Buddy Baker struggles to hold his family together through these trials as he does all he can to be worthy of their love.
3. Batwoman vol 2: To Drown the World
Batwoman is a title whose art is even more compelling than its story—and it has a really fascinating story! An organization called the D.E.O. is blackmailing Kate Kane (in her Batwoman identity) to hunt down her fellow superheroes, chief among them Batman. Meanwhile, children have been going missing in Gotham, and Kate’s girlfriend, Police Lieutenant Maggie Sawyers, is struggling to bring them back. Folktales come to life in the dank alleys of Gotham’s waterfront in this bleak tale with magnificent artwork and one of the most compelling romances in DC’s New 52 lineup.
2. Green Arrow vol 4: The Kill Machine
When The New 52 began, the first few story arcs of Green Arrow were so bad that the series probably only survived cancellation because of its TV show. Then Jeff Lemire took a shot at writing the character and hit the target dead on! Page one opens with an argument. By page three there’s a murder. From there the story goes onto include brutal interrogations, psychotropic dream revelations, arcane secrets revealed, covert ops work, and trick arrows in a story that is shooting ever onward at an alarming speed! Sorrentino’s artwork lends itself to the story with vivid images that are among my favorites in all of comics! This series managed to reinvigorate the title at a time it was desperately languishing. In fact, I will go so far as to say Jeff Lemire’s run of Green Arrow is one of the best the character has ever seen in over 70 years of publication! Needless to say, it hits the mark.
1. Batman vol 3: Death of the Family
If you didn’t know Batman was going to rank number one, you clearly have missed out on this amazing title. There hasn’t been a single bad issue of Batman in The New 52. But of all the stories written, my favorite is “Death of the Family.” This is the most twisted horrific tale of sadistic madness ever to crawl out of the blood-stained walls of Arkham, and it stars the faceless Clown Prince of Crime in his most macabre incarnation to date! Throughout the story, the Joker stalks through Gotham wearing his own flayed face as a mask while preying on everyone Batman loves (from Alfred to the little kitties). Every single Bat-title tied into this story during the crossover, and its finale actually caused me to double over in shock as I turned the pages. Scott Snyder’s writing and Greg Capullo’s art have made Batman the best title in The New 52, and this may be the best story of the whole run!
So there’s the list. And there’s plenty more I could have here. Gotham Academy, Superman/Wonder Woman, Supergirl, Swamp Thing and Superman Unchained are definitely great reads. And from what I’ve heard of Geoff Johns’ Superman run and Green Lantern stories, or all the love titles like Harley Quinn and Red Lantern Corps were getting, they maybe worth checking out too. At the end of the day, this list should probably be a “Top 25” instead of a “Top 15.” But I haven’t read everything, and while a few things I’ve read (such as Batman Eternal and Superman Unchained) really belong on the list, anymore than 15 would have me stretching things out, or vouching for materials I can’t personally verify.
Anyway, I hope this helps, because The New 52 really did have some great things going for it and I’ll be sad to see it come to its end. May these titles help it live on in memory.